17 Sonic Secret Menu Items You Don’t Know Exist

Sonic Secret Menu offers countless delicious items not listed on their standard menu but whispered among those in the know. They are typically made by giving standard menu items a fun twist or combining various ingredients in exciting, new ways.

Since these are unofficial items, many people do not even know they exist. If you are one of them, you are missing out on some truly exceptional flavors.

But, hey, no need to worry – we have got you covered! In this article, we will walk you through the best of Sonic’s Secret Menu items so you can relish them during your next visit.

Sonic Secret Menu Food Items

Here are the top food items you will not find on regular Sonic’s Menu 2024.

1. Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich

Sonic’s Grilled Cheese Sandwiches are a popular breakfast item. Make them protein-rich by adding two slices of salty ham. Request healthy veggies like fresh tomato, onion, and jalapeno in the sandwich for an even more nutritious option.

If you are more of a bacon person, get bacon in place of ham.

2. Extreme Tots

Take Sonic’s regular tots to the next level by adding delicious ingredients, including cheese, chili, onion, jalapeno, and ranch sauce. When combined, all these items make a great treat full of different textures and flavors.

Make sure to order a side of creamy ranch sauce or a refreshing drink like Sonic Limeade to soothe the spice of jalapeno and chili.

You can order Extreme Popcorn Chicken and Extreme Fries by adding the same materials to regular Sonic Popcorn Chicken and Sonic Fries.

Do you know? Sonic Cookie Dough Bites is another discontinued item on their menu.

3. Frito Pie

Are you craving something crunchier than nacho chips? Then try Sonic Frito Pie, which will amaze you from the first bite. Its base ingredient is Frito chips, topped with Sonic special chili and melted cheddar cheese. With it, you can enjoy crunchiness, hot spices, and gooey cheese all in one bite. 

The good thing is that one Frito Pie serving is big enough to count as a meal, ideal for a quick afternoon treat or a party night snack. Not all Sonic staff members know what Frito Pie is. So, just tell them to give you Frito chips with a cheese and chili topping.

4. Pickle O’s

Give pickles a twist by coating them with batter and deep frying until golden brown. You can enjoy them as crispy snacks or add them to your burger for an extra layer of rich flavor.

Sonic pickles were once a part of their menu, but they are no longer offered officially. You can still request their staff to prepare Pickle O’s if they have batter and pickles ready.

5. Ring Leader Loaded Burger

As the name indicates, this burger is loaded with various items, which makes it suitable for people with large appetites.

The “Ring” part of the name comes from the Onion Rings, while the “Loaded” means it is loaded with a hearty beef patty, cheese, bacon, tomato, and grilled onion. You can request different sauces like mayo, mustard, and ketchup with it to customize the flavor to your liking.

5. Hickory Burgers

Hey, BBQ sauce lovers, we have something special for you! Enhance the flavor of your favorite Sonic burger by pairing it with BBQ sauce. Sonic’s secret Hickory Burgers contain a beef patty, cheese slice, bacon, and a special Hickory BBQ sauce that gives them a sweet and sour taste.

And here is a tip: you can transform any Sonic burger into a Hickory burger by replacing its regular sauce with BBQ sauce. Add onion rings, tots, or other items to increase burger’s size, satisfy your appetite, and enhance the flavor.

6. Made-to-Order Burgers

Sonic burgers are known for customizability, and it is also apart from its competitors. So, create your own unique burger by adding existing veggies, patties, and sauces according to your preferences.

If you are feeling particularly hungry, you can amp up your burger with additional patties and further customize it with a blend of various sauces. This flexibility allows you to tailor your burger to your specific cravings and appetite.

7. Sonic Salads

Although Sonic Drive-In is a fast-food chain, it also caters to health-conscious diners with options like Sonic Salads. These fresh salads offer a nutritious balance of chicken, lettuce, red cabbage, carrots, and other garden-fresh items. 

And for those with specific preferences, mix and match items from Sonic’s menu to create a salad that perfectly aligns with your dietary needs.

Looking for discounts at Sonic? Try the Corn Dog Day or the 2 for $5 deal.

Sonic Secret Drinks Menu

Here are the hidden gems in Sonic’s drink collection that usually people don’t know:

1. Sonic Sunrise

It is one of the most popular hidden items and is named for its vibrant hue that mirrors a beautiful sunrise.

This drink is a mixture of equal parts of Sonic Cherry Limeade and Sonic Orange Juice. Since both components have a tangy flavor, the drink may taste bold and zesty in the beginning.

2. Sonic Sunshine Smoothie

If you are tired of having plain ice cream, try this smoothie made from vanilla ice cream, refreshing orange juice, strawberry, and banana.

It contains real fruits, which makes it healthier than other drink options on the Sonic Secret menu. However, you should know that it is still high in sugar. Therefore, make sure you check its calorie count to know how many calories you consume in each delicious sip.

3. Pepper Orgasm

Mix your favorite Dr. Pepper with lemonade and blue Powerade for a sweet yet tangy carbonated drink. It may not have a pretty color, but it tastes amazing. The color is basically dark brown, like Dr. Pepper or Coca-Cola.

If you are with family and do not feel comfortable saying this name loudly, simply state its ingredients. The employee will likely get what you are looking for.

4. Purple Sprite

It is a one-of-a-kind Sprite drink containing cranberry juice, Powerade, and lemonade. Its peculiar purple color makes it an Insta-worthy item, perfect for those who like sharing beautiful things online.

Though this revitalizing drink is commonly called Purple Sprite, Sonic employees may call it Purple Passion and Purple O at some branches.

5. Slap Yo Mama

Sonic Secret Menu items often have quirky names that are catchy and easy to remember. Take “Slap Yo Mama,” for instance, a favorite that is sure to grab your attention.

But what is in this refreshing drink that everyone loves? It is a Powerade slush with lemonade and raspberry flavorings. Powerade is a bit salty, which perfectly complements the sweet lemonade taste. Raspberry is the icing on the top, adding a fruity twist to the slush.

6. Pink Flamingo

Pink drinks are quite popular among Sonic fans, and that is for a good reason. Their vibrant color and refreshing taste offer a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds. Among these, the Pink Flamingo stands out.

It is a Sprite-infused drink. Its key ingredient is Sprite, which contains three tropical flavors: pineapple, orange, and cherry juice. It will certainly transport you to tropical destinations with every sip.

7. Pink Lady

@_audreymartin Have you tried the Pink Lady drink from Sonic yet? #sonic #sonicdrivein #sonicdrinks #pinklady #fyp #foryou ♬ FEEL THE GROOVE – Queens Road, Fabian Graetz

Sonic Pink Lady is another fruity and creamy delight you can enjoy on hot summer days to feel refreshed and energized. Its three main ingredients include Sprite, cherry flavoring, and vanilla cream.

Pink Lady was once a part of Sonic’s menu but was later discontinued. Hence, many Sonic employees can still recognize this name. But if they find it unfamiliar, you can tell them to mix the above-mentioned ingredients to create a perfectly balanced creamy beverage.

8. Pepper Float

Level up your Dr. Pepper game by adding real ice cream above it to create an ice cream delight.

You can sip Dr. Pepper with a straw and enjoy the ice cream with a spoon. Or, if you prefer a more unified taste, stir them together for a blended concoction that combines the best of both worlds.

9. Java Chiller

Finally, here is something for chocolate lovers! Sonic Java Chillers are actually chocolate shakes containing coffee and ice cream. They are topped with whipped cream and your choice of chocolate or caramel syrup.

Enjoy this mouth-watering delight when you crave something creamy and chocolaty with an added energy boost. 

Interested in Sonic drinks? Try ordering from Sonic Slush Menu or Sonic Shakes Menu.

How to order a Sonic Secret Menu item?

As mentioned earlier, Sonic’s Secret Menu is an unofficial fan-created menu of special items with memorable names.

If you are planning to order a secret item, there is a possibility the staff may not be aware of it. 

Hence, it is better to learn what ingredients are used to make that particular item and share them with the staff so they can prepare exactly what you want.

Is it possible to customize a Secret Item?

Yes, it is. Sonic takes customer satisfaction seriously. That is why it lets them customize their food however they want using the available ingredients.

Do all Sonic branches offer these Secret Items?

No, not all branches have this menu. Hence, you should check its availability before visiting your nearby branch. Contact Sonic’s customer service providers via 1-866-657-6642 to get your Secret Menu related queries resolved.

Conclusion

Sonic Secret Menu is an off-the-book creation offering unique items for people of all ages. It has colorful drinks, creamy floats, spicy burgers, and whatnot! Plus, you can customize each item according to your mood and likes.

So, next time you are looking for something wildly delicious and uniquely new, go for hidden gems. They are sure to surprise you with their extraordinary flavors!